Skip to main content

Table 2 Comparism of the Robert Strauss Centre’s complex emergency framework with findings from the Anglophone crisis to determine whether the latter is a complex emergency

From: The ramification of Cameroon’s Anglophone crisis: conceptual analysis of a looming “Complex Disaster Emergency”

Robert Strauss Centre’s complex emergency framework

Relevance to the Anglophone crisis/scores

Scale score

Complex emergency types and themes

Variables

Low relevance

Relevant

Very relevant

Extremely relevant

Theme scores

Types of complex emergency scores

1

2

3

4

Acute

Components

Acute high-intensity conflict: level is higher than the country’s baseline of violent events

   

10

36

Acute environmental disaster

   

High level of poverty

   

Complex social and ethnic geography

   

Relative impact assessment

Large area affected

   

15

Food insecurity price hikes

  

 

High mortality rates

  

 

Concentrated forms of conflict-induced refugees and internally displaced persons

   

Epidemic outbreaks

   

Types of instability

Political (acute conflict): level of violent events higher than the country baseline of recorded events and fatalities

   

11

Environmental (environmental disasters): acute disasters lasting 1 to 15 days (flood, drought, storm, insect infestation, wildfire)

   

Economic (high level of poverty): high poverty (HP) headcount ratio at $1.25 a day (PPP) (% of population)

  

 

Demographic (complex ethnic geography): multiple ethnic groups, demographic pressure

  

 

Chronic

Components

Chronic, low intensity of armed and fatal political violence

  

 

11

29

Vulnerability to climate change-induced hazards

   

High level of poverty: marginalised region

   

Changing demographics between groups

  

 

Relative impact assessment

Large area affected

   

8

Medium-to-high level of displacement: internal, short term, and circular

 

  

Chronic food insecurity: collapse of market and price hikes

 

  

Types of instability

Political (low-intensity conflict): low and persistent level of violent events recorded over 5 years

 

  

10

Environmental (climate-related hazard exposure): chronic and long-lasting disasters of over 15 days (drought, floods)

   

Economic (marginalised region vs. rest of the country)

Low GDP per capita under-development of the region

  

 

Demographic (settlement in camps): refugees, internally displaced persons

   

Urban

Components

High level of civic violence: rioting and protesting

  

 

11

30

High level of exposure to climate change hazards

   

High level of unemployment and high percentage of the under-serviced population

   

Unstable demographic dynamics: rural-urban migration and urban refugees

  

 

Relative impact assessment

Localised affected area

   

9

Epidemic outbreaks

   

Concentrated forms of displacement

  

 

Acute food insecurity: seasonal price hikes

 

  

Large slum population

 

  

Types of instability

Political (urban violence): high level of riots and protests compared to other violence

  

 

10

Environmental (high level of climate-related hazard exposure): rainfall, chronic water scarcity, cyclones, wildfires, floods, and coastal zones

   

Economic (high poverty): urban poverty headcount ratio (% of urban population)

  

 

Demographic (migrants in urban areas)

  

 

Protracted

Components

High level of unemployment and high percentage of the under-serviced population

  

 

16

34

Unstable demographic dynamics: rural-urban migration and urban refugees

  

 

Absence of central authority and protracted conflict with multiple non-state actors

  

 

Severe vulnerability to climate change-induced reoccurring and sudden disasters

   

High level of poverty and collapse of state and local economies

  

 

Disturbed demographics

  

 

Relative impact assessment

Transnational with local hotspots

   

6

Epidemic outbreaks

   

Chronic food insecurity and famine: food availability

 

  

Intermittent phases of displacement

 

  

Types of instability

Political (protracted conflict): constant high level of violent events and fatalities recorded with periods of over 5 years of acute conflict

   

12

Environmental (high level of climate-related hazard exposure): long-lasting disasters of over 15 days (drought, floods)

   

Economic (collapse of the national economy): national GDP drop, high poverty headcount ratio at $1.25 a day (PPP) (% of population)

  

 

Demographic (high population of refugees and internally displaced persons): collapse of life expectancy

   

Total scores

14

7

19

11

  

Percentage of scores

27.5

13.5

37.5

21.5